Rent or buy at 7.40%?
Maya buys; Jordan keeps renting. Same city, same savings. Two invented people, built from published US national figures: a $417,500 home (median existing-home price, all housing types, September 2026), a 7.40% mortgage (Freddie Mac survey average, week ending 15 October 2026) and $2,266 a month rent (typical single-family asking rent, September 2026). Your local numbers will differ.
Your browser can't play this video here. Read the decision page instead.
2 min 6 s · captions on screen · narrated by Vera, our AI presenter. Maya and Jordan are invented.
- Same savings$96,025 each
What buying takes: 20% down plus 3% closing costs on a $417,500 home. Maya spends it on the home; Jordan invests it.
- Year 1, each month$940 more a month to ownOwning $3,227 − renting $2,287 = $940
Separately, about $262 a month of Maya's mortgage payment repays the loan (year-1 average). Jordan invests the yearly difference.
- If Maya has to sell after 3 yearsJordan ahead by $43,739
Buying costs plus selling costs at the year-3 sale: $39,898 (3% closing on the price, 6% selling on the home's value then).
Illustration · Before income and capital gains taxes - Seven years onJordan ahead by $50,601Wealth after 7 years: Maya $176,385 · Jordan $226,987
If Jordan spends each year's difference instead of investing it, Maya is ahead by $31,999.
Illustration · Before income and capital gains taxes
Investing rather than spending those yearly savings leaves Jordan about $82,600 wealthier after seven years, under these assumptions.
Jordan's wealth after 7 years: $226,987 − $144,386 = $82,601
Illustration · Before income and capital gains taxesSeven-year break-even: Jordan invests ≈39% of each year's housing-cost savings.Under this example's assumptions. At that share the two are level, so Jordan is not ahead; 39% is rounded.
The free Rent vs Buy model arrives in the welcome email when you sign up for the newsletter.
How long would you stay?
After 7 years, if Jordan invests the same up-front cash and each year's difference.
Two modest changes together (faster home price growth and a lower mortgage rate) can reverse the result.
Illustration · Before income and capital gains taxesEvery input with its source and date, the tests we ran, what the model leaves out (including taxes), and a worksheet. No sign-up needed.
- Yr 1$39,699
- Yr 2$41,758
- Yr 3$43,739
- Yr 4$45,630
- Yr 5$47,414
- Yr 6$49,077
- Yr 7$50,601
- Yr 8$51,968
- Yr 9$53,155
- Yr 10$54,142
Calculated by the free Rent vs Buy model (last updated 18 October 2026), from the example household above. Annual investing; income and capital gains taxes not modelled. An illustration, not a forecast.
Every issue has the same three parts.
The decision
One question a real household is facing, set out as a choice between options. No answer assumed.
The workings
A free decision page for each episode: every number with its source and date, the assumptions, the tests, and what would change the answer.
The model
The Rent vs Buy spreadsheet is free and works in Excel. Later episodes say whether their model is free or paid, and what a paid version adds.
See the sources. Check the assumptions. Follow the calculation.
VeraAI HOST
Presents the weekly video.
- A public example and decision page for every episode, with no sign-up needed.
- Source dates and the date each model was last updated, on every page. Rent or buy: Freddie Mac, NAR and Zillow figures from September and October 2026; the Rent vs Buy model was last updated 18 October 2026.
- What we leave out, said plainly. The rent-or-buy example is an illustration before income and capital gains taxes: taxes can materially change the comparison.
- Corrections are listed, with their date, on the page they affect. Found an error? Email [email protected].
- No recommendations of financial products, and no advice on your personal situation. Education, not advice.
Written by a chartered accountant with 15 years in banking.
Founding members
- Membership
- Every model and decision pack, a monthly walkthrough of a household-and-business "board pack", and the library of decision memos.
- Own a business? The Safe to Pay planner
- How much you can safely pay yourself over the next 13 weeks.
Nothing to pay now. Join the waitlist and you'll hear first when either opens.
Join the waitlistThis opens an email to us. If it doesn't, write to [email protected] with the subject "Waitlist". Privacy notice
Get the free newsletter + the Rent vs Buy model.
- Enter your email on our sign-up page.
- Click Confirm in the short email we send you.
- Your welcome email brings the Rent vs Buy model and a link to the decision page.
- Then one decision a week, about five minutes of reading.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. We never sell your email address; our email provider, beehiiv, stores and processes it to send the newsletter. Can't see our emails? Check your Promotions tab or spam. Privacy notice