For renters who have saved for a down payment and are weighing whether to buy. One example household built from published national figures from different sources, not one specific home; your local numbers will differ.
The short answer, for this example (before tax):
Cash up front: buying takes $96,025 (20% down plus closing costs).
Each month, year 1: owning takes $940 more cash than renting. Separately, about $262 a month of the mortgage payment repays the loan (year-1 average; it is part of the payment, not part of the $940).
Over time, in this example, before taxes: if the renter invests the same cash and each year's difference, the renter is ahead by $43,739 after three years and $50,601 after seven.
How sure can we be? Renting is ahead in this before-tax example. The result also depends on the combination of your local costs, financing and future returns. Before-tax illustration. Taxes can materially change the comparison; individual tax circumstances are not modelled.
What "ahead" means: the buyer's home equity after assumed selling costs, plus any investments, compared with the renter's investment balance, before taxes, in dollars at that future date. It is not income either household earns each year, and home equity is not cash you can spend while you still own the home.
Fill this in for your own situation. Calculate the totals yourself; nothing here adds up automatically. Then print the worksheet to keep it. Nothing you type is saved or sent anywhere, and it is lost if you close the page.
1. Cash left after buying
2. Your three local numbers
Put these into the free model to see your own before-tax result.
3. Talk it through together
If two of you are deciding, each answer these separately first, then compare before looking at the numbers again.
Prompt
Person 1
Person 2
What matters most to me in this decision?
What outcome worries me most?
What trade-off could I accept?
The full workings
1. The options
Buy the home with 20% down and a 30-year fixed mortgage at 7.40%.
Rent a comparable home and invest the cash a buyer would need up front, plus the difference in cash each year.
2. What cash does buying require?
Buy
Rent
Label
Cash up front
$96,025
$0 modelled (see note)
Calculated
Year 1, per month (average)
$3,227
$2,287
Calculated
Difference, per month
Owning takes $940 more cash
Calculated
Owning = mortgage, property tax, insurance and upkeep; about $262 a month of the mortgage payment (year-1 average) repays the loan. Renting = rent plus renter's insurance. The model does not include a rental deposit, advance rent or moving costs, so renting also takes some cash up front in practice. With less than 20% down, mortgage insurance usually applies and the comparison changes. This page does not assess affordability: it does not know your income, budget or savings. Use the worksheet above for that.
3. If they move early
If they leave after…
Position, before tax
Label
3 years
Renter ahead by $43,739
Calculated
7 years
Renter ahead by $50,601
Calculated
10 years
Renter ahead by $54,142
Calculated
What each has after seven years (the video's Maya and Jordan)
After 7 years, before tax
Amount
Label
Buyer (Maya): home equity after selling costs, plus any investments
$176,385
Calculated
Renter (Jordan): investments
$226,987
Calculated
If the renter keeps the starting $96,025 invested but spends each year's difference instead of investing it
Buyer ahead by $31,999
Calculated
What investing each year's difference is worth to the renter
$82,601
Calculated
Seven-year break-even: Jordan invests ≈39% of each year's housing-cost savings. Under this example's assumptions. Calculated
At that share, the two are level after seven years: Jordan is not ahead. 39% is rounded; the exact share is 38.74%. Investing a larger share leaves Jordan ahead, a smaller one leaves Maya ahead. Checked by re-running the model with Jordan investing that share of each year's difference. Before income and capital gains taxes.
Both start with the same $96,025. The renter's lead depends on investing the difference every year. In the last row, the renter's starting savings grow at the assumed 6% a year for seven years ($144,386), with nothing added; the buyer's position is unchanged. Maya and Jordan in the video are invented people used to illustrate this example.
Staying longer does not automatically make buying better: in this example the renter's lead grows between three, seven and ten years. The buyer pays 3% closing costs to buy and 6% selling costs on the home's value when she sells ($39,898 together at the year-3 sale in this example), so an early move is expensive, but those costs are not the only reason the gap changes over time: rent, ownership costs, home value growth and investment returns all move it. This compares an early sale; it does not test financial resilience. For that, use the cash-left calculation in the worksheet, based on all essential spending, not housing alone.
4. What changes the result
Each forecast assumption is moved by 1 percentage point in the direction that helps buying, first one at a time, then two together. The model is re-run for every row. These are illustrations, not predictions.
Change from the example
Test
After 7 years, before tax
None (the example)
Baseline
Renter ahead by $50,601
Home value growth 4% (from 3%)
One change
Renter ahead by $19,105
Mortgage rate at purchase 6.40% (from 7.40%)
One change
Renter ahead by $23,308
Return on invested savings 5% (from 6%)
One change
Renter ahead by $38,691
Rent growth 4% (from 3%)
One change
Renter ahead by $43,539
Home value growth 4% (from 3%) and mortgage rate at purchase 6.40% (from 7.40%)
Two together
Buyer ahead by $8,188
Home value growth 4% (from 3%) and return on invested savings 5% (from 6%)
Two together
Renter ahead by $7,158
Home value growth 4% (from 3%) and rent growth 4% (from 3%)
Two together
Renter ahead by $12,043
Mortgage rate at purchase 6.40% (from 7.40%) and return on invested savings 5% (from 6%)
Two together
Renter ahead by $12,073
Mortgage rate at purchase 6.40% (from 7.40%) and rent growth 4% (from 3%)
Two together
Renter ahead by $16,246
Return on invested savings 5% (from 6%) and rent growth 4% (from 3%)
Two together
Renter ahead by $31,743
Renting stays ahead in each of the single changes shown. One of the 17 tested cases reverses it: home value growth 4% (from 3%) and mortgage rate at purchase 6.40% (from 7.40%), together. The mortgage-rate rows mean a different rate at purchase, not refinancing later. In the model, buying first comes out ahead in year 28 under the example's assumptions; across the cases tested on this page the break-even year ranges from year 6 to beyond 30 years. The break-even year is highly sensitive to assumptions, including when savings are invested, so we do not rely on it.
5. Illustrative tests of local facts
Facts you can check, each changed by an illustrative amount; the model is re-run for every row. The size of each change was chosen by us, so read this as how much each fact can move the answer, not as a ranking of which fact matters most for everyone.
If your local figure is…
After 7 years, before tax
The fact to get
Rent $100 a month higher
Renter ahead by $39,651
Rent for a comparable home nearby
Rent $100 a month lower
Renter ahead by $61,552
Rent for a comparable home nearby
Property tax 0.6% instead of 1.1%
Renter ahead by $31,552
Local property tax rate
Property tax 1.6% instead of 1.1%
Renter ahead by $69,650
Local property tax rate
Home insurance $1,000 a year higher
Renter ahead by $59,727
Insurance quote
Closing costs 5% instead of 3%
Renter ahead by $63,157
Lender's Loan Estimate
HOA or mortgage insurance $200 a month
Renter ahead by $72,502
HOA dues / mortgage insurance quote
Test values are illustrative (Assumed). Results are model results (Calculated).
6. How sure can we be?
Sensitive to assumptions. Renting is ahead in this before-tax example. The result also depends on the combination of your local costs, financing and future returns.
What we tested: the result after seven years, before tax, with each forecast assumption moved 1 point alone and in pairs (section 4), and seven local facts changed (section 5).
What held: Renting stays ahead in each of the single changes shown.
What reversed it: One of the 17 tested cases reverses it: home value growth 4% (from 3%) and mortgage rate at purchase 6.40% (from 7.40%), together.
What is not modelled and could matter: taxes. This is a before-tax illustration. Taxes can materially change the comparison. The effect depends on the household's tax circumstances, investment account, deduction benefit and eligibility for a home-sale exclusion. We have not calculated an after-tax result for this example. Also the timing of investing, which the model does once a year.
How we describe results: "held across the cases tested" when nothing we tested reverses it; "sensitive to assumptions" when reasonable changes, alone or together, reverse it; "close in the scenarios shown" when the difference is small for a household; "insufficient information" when a decisive input is missing. These describe the evidence on this page; they are not probabilities.
7. Not in the numbers
Stability, flexibility to move, schools and neighborhood, and the time and work of owning a home. These are real at every point of the decision; weigh them alongside the numbers.
8. Your next facts to get
Rent for a genuinely comparable home nearby: same size and type, not a smaller apartment.
The full monthly cost of owning: principal and interest, property tax, home insurance, maintenance, HOA dues, mortgage insurance if you put down less than 20%, and any extra utilities an owner pays. A lender's Loan Estimate shows the payment; if that payment already includes property tax and insurance (escrow), do not add them a second time.
How long you are likely to stay. The result depends heavily on it.
9. Assumptions and sources
Input
Value
Label
Source or basis
Mortgage rate, 30-year fixed
7.40%
Observed
Freddie Mac PMMS, week ending 15 Oct 2026. A national survey average; using it for this household is our assumption, and your own quote will differ.
Home price
$417,500
Observed
NAR median existing-home price for all housing types, September 2026 (released 13 Oct 2026)
Rent
$2,266/month
Observed
Zillow typical single-family asking rent, September 2026 (released 15 Oct 2026)
Down payment
20%
Assumed
Example choice
Mortgage term
30 years
Assumed
Example choice
Closing costs
3% of price
Assumed
Example within a typical range; your Loan Estimate gives the real figure
Property tax
1.1% of value a year
Assumed
Example; varies widely by location
Home insurance
$2,200 a year
Assumed
Example; get a quote
Maintenance
1% of value a year
Assumed
Example; older homes usually cost more
HOA and other owner costs
$0 a month
Assumed
Example; many homes have HOA dues
Growth in insurance, HOA and renter's insurance
3% a year
Assumed
Example assumption
Renter's insurance
$250 a year
Assumed
Example value
Home value growth
3% a year
Assumed
A future rate nobody can know; see section 4
Rent growth
3% a year
Assumed
A future rate nobody can know; see section 4
Return on invested savings
6% a year
Assumed
After fees, before tax; a future rate nobody can know; see section 4
Selling costs
6% of sale price
Assumed
Example within a typical range
Years compared
7 years
Assumed
Example horizon; change it to your own
When savings are invested
Once a year, at year end
Assumed
Model convention; investing monthly would change the results, most noticeably the break-even year
Taxes
Not modelled
Assumed
Before-tax illustration; see section 6
Observed = a published figure with its date. Assumed = a choice about the future or an example value. Calculated = the model's result from those inputs.
Model, status and corrections
Model: Rent vs Buy Decision Model, last updated 18 October 2026 (download). Numbers on this page and in the video are read from the model by the same build. Status: Published 18 October 2026. Corrections: none yet; once published, every correction will be listed here with its date. Found an error? Email [email protected].